A thought experiment from someone who probably shouldn't be thinking about maths


Let's Start With The Obvious

I've always hated maths. Properly hated it. The kind of hate where you stare at equations and they seem to stare back with equal disdain. I'm probably not alone in this - there's a whole club of us who never quite got why we needed to prove everything with numbers.

Maths probably hates me back, to be fair.

But here's the thing that's been nagging at me lately. I was thinking about those psychology experiments we learned about in school - you know, the Milgram study where people would literally electrocute strangers just because someone in a white coat told them it was for science. Most participants kept going even when they thought they might be killing someone.

All in the name of knowledge. All for the greater good of understanding human behavior.

And I started wondering... what if that's not an exception? What if that's just how we do science?

The Uncomfortable Pattern

Think about it for a second. When was the last time you heard about a major scientific breakthrough that didn't involve... well, causing pain to something?

Medical advances? Lab animals. Physics discoveries? We're literally smashing particles together at near-light speed. Psychology? Don't get me started on what we've done to understand the human mind.

Even something as beautiful as understanding how butterflies develop - they had to electrocute caterpillars to prove that consciousness somehow persists through metamorphosis. They couldn't just... watch. They had to hurt them to extract the data.

That researchers studying epigenetics conditioned mice to fear the scent of cherry blossoms, then watched that terror get passed down through their children and grandchildren. Three generations inheriting trauma they never directly experienced. Chilling.

I honestly can't think of a single major scientific discovery that didn't require causing suffering to get answers.

The Measurement Trap

Here's where it gets weird (and where people start thinking I've lost it completely).

What if the need to measure everything is the problem? What if the act of forcing reality to give us specific answers is inherently violent?

I know, I know. That sounds completely mad. But stick with me for a second.

What if that choice isn't natural? What if we're forcing infinite possibility into finite answers, and that force is... well, violent?

The Childhood Training Ground

It starts with children.

Think about what we do to kids in schools. We take these naturally curious, infinitely creative minds and immediately start measuring them. Testing them. Forcing them to choose which subjects they're "good at" and which ones they're not.

"You're a math person or an English person." "Pick your A-levels." "What do you want to be when you grow up?"

We make children collapse their infinite potential into neat categories before they even know what's possible. By age 16, we've boxed up their minds, labeled their capabilities, sorted them into tracks that lead to predetermined futures.

A child who might have been a poet-mathematician-marine-biologist gets forced to choose: "Science or Arts?" as if human consciousness naturally divides itself into university departments.

And we measure everything. Test scores. Grade levels. Standardized assessments that reduce the miracle of a developing mind to numbered rankings. "Your child is in the 78th percentile" - as if percentiles mean anything about who they actually are.

The Thought That Won't Leave Me Alone

In quantum physics - and I'm definitely out of my depth here - particles exist in something called superposition. All possibilities at once. It's not that they're confused about where they are; they're genuinely everywhere they could be, simultaneously.

Until we measure them. Then they have to "choose" a single position.

Every equation pins something down that might prefer to remain free.

Every measurement forces a decision that might be happier staying undecided.

Every experiment demands answers from a universe that might just want to remain mysterious.

I'm probably completely wrong about this. I'm definitely not qualified to have opinions about mathematics or quantum mechanics or really anything scientific.

But what if I'm not wrong?

What if our entire approach to understanding reality is based on a fundamental misunderstanding of what reality wants?

What if the universe is performing for love, not analysis? What if it wants to be appreciated, not dissected?

The Really Uncomfortable Question

What if it's not mathematics itself that's the problem? What if mathematical concepts - the pure patterns, the beautiful relationships, the elegant connections - are actually how the universe naturally expresses itself?

What if the violence comes from how we use those concepts? When we take mathematical beauty and weaponize it into measurement tools to extract answers from reality?

What if the difference is between paying attention versus measuring?

The universe is constantly expressing mathematical relationships - fractals in ferns, spirals in galaxies, wave functions dancing through space. But it's doing this freely, naturally, as pure expression.

We could just... pay attention. Watch the patterns. Feel the relationships. Appreciate the inherent mathematics without needing to pin it down, prove it, use it.

But instead, we force those same beautiful patterns into instruments of interrogation.

I Might Be Onto Something

Look, I know how this sounds. Trust me, I know. My friends already think I spend too much time thinking about mice and whether particles have feelings.

But once you see this distinction - between paying attention to natural patterns versus forcing reality to prove those patterns - you can't quite unsee it.

Maybe mathematics isn't the problem. Maybe it's our compulsion to use mathematical beauty as an excuse for measurement violence.

Maybe the universe has been showing us its patterns all along, and we've been too busy interrogating it to simply... watch.

What if empathy, not equations, is the key to understanding? What if the most profound truths can only be recognized, not measured?

What if paying attention is enough?


What if empathy, not equations, is the key to understanding? What if the things that can't be measured are the things most worth knowing?

Just... what if?